PV Meet-up Gone Bad Emails
I want to present the full details available via emails to fully explain the sequence of events leading up to Evening Ransom producing the PV meet-up gone bad videos. There remain questions about exactly how things unfolded and what emails exist. As of today October 23, Kim Wilson has put of a "Narcissists: Obsessed, Envious, Disordered" video that is full of lies and completely contradictory to the emails she sent. Here I illustrate the full timeline and exchanges between Kim and Evening. I will also demonstrate how one can verify the integrity of an email by looking at your authenticated received chain headers.
The timeline starts with a cocktail party hosted by Evening at her room on Sunday September 16. Early in the morning of September 17, L and David have the first bad interaction. It is not until September 21 that Evening receives the first email indicating that a problem had occurred.
In the timeline, the first email thread is labelled with the green msg1 through msg5 boxes. Separate emails threads labelled t2_msg1 through t2_msg4, t3_msg and t4_msg1 through t4_msg2 are also shown. The bottom pink and purple boxes show when videos from Kim and Evening are being put up.
Let’s begin with the first msg1:
This shows the full contents of the email as known by the email server. It includes a number of lines known as headers that provide metadata about the msg. These include lines like ARC-Seal:…, ARC-Authentication-Results:…, and DKIM-Signature:…, all of which provide an integrity check of the sender and the contents of the message. These can be used to verify that the message is valid and unmodified from the sender. This uses what are know as cryptographic signatures, a technology used pervasively to validate information content in everything from email to bitcoin, banking, and every secure connection made on the web. Every message I will show has this information available for validation by an expert witness in a court case. If you want to look into the details, I suggest starting with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authenticated_Received_Chain.
In the text of the emails that following, only Evening’s, Kim’s and David’s names are used. Other peoples names have been replaced with a single letter mnemonic. Kim's emails are shown in red text, Evening's emails are shown in blue text. My commentary on the thread continues in the black text as seen in this paragraph. Note that I have just watched Kim's latest video where she attempts to put a spin on what really happened. Frankly she has just dug a massive hole by introducing more inconsistencies between what she says in these emails and what she says in the video.
Now, the text of msg1 from Kim on Fri, 21 Sep 2018 18:10:49:
The girls and `I have been watching your videos pretty steady and we all
agree that you might be the best person to talk to.
We have had a very odd experience during this meet-up and we would all
very much to chat with you about it.
In total there are 5 of us, and we would be available to Skype, Zoom,
email, text....whatever works for you.
Please do not mention this email to anyone outside of this group of
me, K, D, J and L.
If you are able to chat, I will forward their email addresses to you.
leave tomorrow, but could chat anytime once they arrive back home.
Thank you so very much
I hope to hear back from you soon
Ok, so something happened and Evening is being asked to help out on Fri Sep 21 at 18:10. Evening replies with msg1_reply:
Sure Kim. I'd be honored to talk to you guys. I ended up feeling
that I didn't even get a photo with you. I saw the ladies as your
so didn't ask them for numbers or anything like that, but I did
they would at least find my videos at some point and say hello. I
really open in terms of time. I'm just home packing up my house
every day!! I was trying to record a follow up video for my own
haven't even gotten to that so far. You can text me to get through
if you want to. xxx-xxx-xxx.
Kim responds with the following msg2 on Sat, 22 Sep 2018 12:20:18:
Thank you so much for your reply.
Something very strange happened here. There was a super predator amongst
L was aggressively attacked, sexually harassed in a very deviant
manner, held hostage, isolated, manipulated, screamed at, called names,
humiliated, threatened and all communication and interaction were
manipulated. Every attempt to get people together was controlled and
I want to fill you in, but this creepy narc freak was talking behind
everyone's back and pulling all the strings, I want to include everyone in
this conversation because after this covert manipulation I would not feel
OK mentioning anyone's name unless there was full transparency.
I don't want any part of talking behind anyone's back. So I am attaching
everyone, except for J because I can not find her email address. It is
somewhere, likely buried in a thread. But I hope someone will add her to
this thread and forward this email.
Something very strange just happened here in PV Evening, we all saw it, and
we think there is important info here, not to mention we just discovered a
super predator hiding amongst us.
What took our narcs years to achieve, this creep manage to pull off in a
matter of 24 hours.
This creep pulled strings to keep us all apart, isolate us from one another
and thou K was immediately alerted, it took the rest of us a few days
to realize what was happening. Thou ultimately it was L’s account of
what had happened to her that blew the lid off this entire event.
This is a pretty strange story Evening. They are genuine predators, they
are all working off a collective hive mind and thou it took several of us a
few days to see it, me included, a real monster just exposed itself in a
very public way. And I will admit that I was instantly confused by the
gaslighting and control tactics.
Thank God, most of my communication with the thing is in writing and now
Did you pick up any strange energy Evening?
Are you able to mediate this conversation?
I just want full disclosure and transparency between all of us, because
this creep just manipulated 9 people with total ease.
With best regards
Ok, without saying who exactly this "super predator" is, this email is already starting to completely contradict her "Narcissists: Obsessed, Envious, Disordered" video. First of all, if the initial interaction with David and L were as she described where David was looking for some Nirvana healing session with a group of victims, and L was some sex obsessed slut, there is no way that this email would not have questioned what happened. Second, instead of vouching for David in glowing terms as she does in the video, here she is claiming he is talking behind everyone's back and is asking Evening if she picked up on any strange vibe. How do these two things reconcile? Where is the mention of the message she says she got from David indicating that there was a problem with L? Where is the we need to get both sides of the story before rushing to judgement? No, Kim here is completely sold that L is telling the truth and that David is a "super predator".
Evening responds to Kim's email with two separate responses, msg2_reply1 on Sat, Sep 22, 2018 at 6:25 PM:
When do you guys want to talk, and how should we go about it?
and msg2_reply2 on Sat, Sep 22, 2018 at 6:47:
I don't know what took this email so long to show up as I've been looking
for it since you first mentioned this issue yesterday. I apologize if
you've been waiting on me. Now, if we are talking about David yes, I did
pick up on some very controlling and aggressive vibes. I had the
impression that he wasn't hanging out with you guys as much as you had
expected, and I was having such a hard time meeting back up with you that I
didn't know there was this much interaction between all of you or with
David. After hearing that he didn't help out with the airport transports
and all that and seeing that he did two lengthy videos from his room, it
looked like he was kind of doing his own thing, which given the male/female
ratio at the event I figured was probably the best thing. Please fill me
in on what happened and when.
Talk soon I hope,
Understand that the meet-up is over and we are all back home. Evening's comment about the male/female ratio is based on the fact that she never even knew there was another man at the meet-up until it was over. They met Kim and David for dinner on Friday, and said David seemed fine, but Kim was out of control being rude and obnoxious but they wrote it off to how “pissed” (drunk, they are Brits) she was, and expected to get a clearer impression of her over the next few days. Never did they expect that it would be impossible to connect with Kim again or to meet any of the other participants. They saw David on Saturday for lunch and were unable to connect with him again after that. We were in the hotel right next to them and never even knew it. They did not know about the party at my place on Sunday. The meet-up for them essentially amounted to a dinner Friday and a lunch Saturday, both were arranged by them. No more interactions with Kim and only rather shocking and rude interactions with David, but do not see them again, and never meet anyone else. At this point Evening believes David is the only man other than her husband who attended. )
Now a second email thread starts, on which the t2_msg1 from Kim beginning on Sun, 23 Sep 2018 08:36:04:
I believe that everyone but D made it home safely. She was bumped from
her flight, some silly issue about having to be sober on flights...LOL!
It took a little work to find her, but I did. I am picking her up this
morning and she will be staying here at my house, until we can get her
another flight, maybe Monday or Tuesday on Alaska!
But she is great, cheery as always, and I am happy to have a roommate for a
few days, so everything is good!
I agree with K 100%, this needs to be addressed, dealt with,
exposed....whatever it takes.
This is no garden-variety narc, this is a Super Predator.
This narc played us all, with the greatest of ease, moving us around like
chessmen. The level of covert manipulation was incredible to watch and gave
me a heightened level of insight, so I am not as bothered by that as much.
I am not happy about it, but L is the real issue here. It was like
watching the movie Gaslight, in real time. Truly amazing to watch first
My real issue is what happened to L, that was too bloody much, and that
in itself is cause for extreme alarm within our community. The anger,
aggression, isolation, mind control, humiliation, name-calling and the fear
he caused in her....no fucking way, not on my watch! If we know about this
and do nothing, we are simply not very good people and I want to be a good
person. L deserves to be treated with respect and dignity. This was an
extremely aggressive attack on her, and I believe he is dangerous and 100%
capable of harming a victim.
And the speed he was moving at....shocking! It took our ex-narcs years to
pull off what this super creep could do in a matter of 24 hours.
J and E were completely isolated from the rest of us, I was told
several times, that communication with them, needed to go through him, as
they were either both narcs, or one was a narc and terrorizing the other,
and then the story would change again. Every time I tried to chat with him
about contacting J & E, he would go into some rant, and I would be standing
there utterly confused.....like that wasn't a red flag! I asked repeatedly
for his cell number, J and E. I asked where they were staying and
he would say he didn't know and a few hours later he would tell me he had
been with them. I was told that they wanted to be alone, they kept moving
hotels, they were narcs, everything should go through him. I feel like a
complete fool for not spotting the manipulation immediately.
There were 6 women here that wanted very much to meet E and spend time
with her, and she was completely isolated from the rest of us. Thank God I
had a chance to meet her, and she is lovely. It is a real loss that we did
not get to spend more time with her. I am pretty pissed off about the E
And I feel like a fool, all the signs were there, I felt confused,
frustrated, unsure of what to do. All of the uncomfortable emotions were
He was bad mouthing all of us to each other, making people feel unwanted,
unimportant.....but no worries, he was there for us! LMFAO!
Now he is scrambling, in full narc panic mode, trying to find himself an
ally, a flying money, someone to back up his shit.
This guy is really smooth, truly a master manipulator, and watching it
unfold right before my eyes, was a real wake up call.
The aggressive, deviant sexually charged assault against L, would have
landed his ass in a Mexican jail had we figured out what he had done to her
sooner. Mexico has laws too! And that shit simply doesn't fly here.
After hearing L’s story and the obvious trail he left 100% confirms her
accuracy and the account of the situation....OMG!
Telling me he wasn't getting my messages, not answering the phone in his
room, not opening the door to me when I was trying to find him. Telling me
in the morning that he would pass on info about beach get-togethers,
dinners out, going dancing etc. to J & E, and then saying he hadn't heard
from them and in the next moment saying he had been with them.
WTF? Honestly? Divide and conquer, it was a chess game, and we were the
Getting us lost the night we were heading to Evenings and blaming J for
giving him bad directions and then saying he never talked to J about
it.....it was a shit show. I did call him out on that because his BS was
getting really thick at that point and he back paddled his way out of that
lie. It had nothing to do with J….nothing at all. He did not want us
going to Evenings, he was mad as hell all night because we were going
there, he later said they stole his Tequilla.....like WTF?
In passing while still driving I did say...hum, maybe not dude, they didn't
appear to be in need of booze, nor did they seem the type to steal
someone's Tequilla. Likely seriously? He was very angry, abnormally angry
about the Tequilla. And I am wondering if that is what triggered the attack
on L, because he was pissed about that. Thou he did seem angry most of
the time, he was really mad about that.
He didn't want to go to the beach, not to dinner, not out dancing, nada,
and he never wanted to go to Evenings that night. And he made sure he
controlled communication to ensure people did not get together. And thou I
was communicating with him on Skype he continued to say he never got my
messages. Then after he does all of that, he tells L, things are
disorganized.....well, no shit!
For those of us that were in direct communication with each other, we
managed just fine to meet-up, spend time at the beach, get together for
dinner and go out dancing. We were hanging out together at each other's
And we owe L a big night out dancing.....next year L, for certain!
And the crap he pulled in front of Andela's Rest. with L? Are you
kidding me? The brazen nerve of the shameless creep! Zero shame, zero
remorse, nothing but narc supply and a smirk! And speed in which he was
able to mind sweep L, is fucking shocking.
She was instantly under his control, willing to have sex with him, so he
would stop scaring her, stop calling her names, stop screaming sexually
deviant remarks at her. She was instantly scared, instantly willing to do
whatever it was going to take to calm him down and reduce the threat of
personal harm or violent attack, instantly on eggshells. And he did it
within a matter of hours. And Thank God, she knew how to calm that narc
down, because I 100% believe him to be a very real danger.
This guy is the biggest narc hiding within our community. The biggest
threat to victims and survivors....full stop! He is far creepier than HG.
by miles. Our community is a magnet for these creatures and they have to be
flushed out into the light where people can see them for what they are.
Bless your hearts each and everyone of you
Again, Kim is completely bashing David, providing details of how he was behaving in anti-social ways in his interactions with everyone at PV, not just L. How does this reconcile with the effusive comments about David she is making in the video? It does not. Kim is lying in her comments about never sending any emails. She is lying about how the interactions in PV went in her video as well.
Evening responds with t2_msg1_reply on Sun, 23 Sep 2018 11:22:22:
Just complete and total drama. On the tequila, he presented it like a gift
which is a normal thing to do when you are a gift in someone's home.
Regardless, if he didn't want to leave it why did he? We had a counter top
full of bottles of tequila and didn't need his, but its clear that he
wanted to look like a generous, polished gentleman but clearly hoped we
would tackle him at the door and force him to take back his "gift." He
sent a follow up email the next day where he thanked us for a nice time and
of course there is no mention of the tequila! Seems his "anger" was
contrived. The point here is mostly that he is establishing a pattern, and
sadly what happened was somewhat predictable and though I didn't know what
the harm would be exactly, I did feel protective of the women that came and
was trying to meet back up with you to make sure everything was okay for
the next two nights, and why I made it clear that I had extra room should
anyone need it. I didn't think it was a safe environment for anyone so
early in their recovery, and did see that L needed to be protected from
David because I didn't expect her to have decent boundaries because none of
us did/do early in our recovery, and because she was led to believe that
David was safe and trustworthy because of his association with Kim. In the
interest of transparency to use Kim's word, I think the nature of the
relationship between Kim and David as well as between Kim and other
channels needs to be shared with the viewers because at this point it
really does appear that Kim was vouching for David's character and
expertise and because of that thousands of people are now listening to him
having no idea who he really is. This is time for a simple "I was wrong"
video that makes it clear that you are no longer supporting David's channel
and that you see him as a dangerous threat to vulnerable people. *Kim
needs to quickly come out with a statement separating herself from David in
my opinion. *
Even outside of an overt attack there were problems but I wasn't clear what
the cause was, and am still not entirely clear on it. Obviously David was
a problem, for instance, why did he say he didn't want to come to my place
and why then did he come and why did his desires impact what anyone else
was doing? Did you, Kim, see any red flags in the months you've been
working together? It seems there was a discrepancy between the way you
both saw your involvement with this event. To me it looked like David was
going to assist Kim in putting it on, but when you came to my place it
seemed David was there as any other subscriber as he claimed no
responsibility for getting people from the airport and so on, but it seems
he also felt somewhat in charge as well in terms of dictating the agenda
and communication . What was your agreement or understanding with David
going into this event? Were there other participants that came to the meet
up that I didn't even know about? Were J and E David's
subscribers? Still trying to understand the sequence of events and get a
clear picture on what everyone was thinking going into this event.
So Evening responds that Kim needs to have a statement of separation from David and asks about any red flags from working together previously.
Kim’s next msg in the thread is t2_msg3 which is a reply to L on Sun, 23 Sep 2018 15:04:29:
He had a bee in his bonnet about E for certain. You ladies did not see
E, but holy cow! Beauty Queen, sweet, soft-spoken, humble,
charming.....she was threatening to him in some way, for sure, I saw that
And the homophobia, gay bashing steadily. And blaming J for some sort of
exposure he had to gay men.
I contacted several of my closest gay friends and tried to explain his
aggression towards gay people, and they all said....that is a really bad
sign. Plus he had us take hi